Domestic Violence
Domestic Violence Defense Attorney Joe Simon Named a Top Ten Criminal Defense Attorney in Michigan by Leading Lawyers Magazine Peer-Review Poll. 5-Star Rated.
Defending Domestic Violence Charges in Southeast Michigan
Domestic Violence charges in Michigan are serious and can have life-altering consequences resulting in a criminal history and denial of the right to use or possess firearms or weapons. These charges can arise from situations involving physical harm or even threats of physical harm between individuals in a domestic relationship. If you are facing domestic violence charges, it is crucial to understand the legal landscape and the defense strategies available in order to protect your rights.
Understanding Domestic Violence Charges in Michigan
In Michigan, domestic violence involves an assault and/or battery committed against a spouse, former spouse, dating partner, cohabitant, or someone with whom the accused shares a child. The severity of the charges depends on the degree of the alleged conduct and the existence of any prior convictions. A first-time offense, without aggravating circumstances, is typically charged as a misdemeanor punishable by up to 93 days in jail, a fine of up to $500 and up to two years of probation with rigorous conditions including substantial counseling obligations. Repeat offenses or incidents involving serious injury or use of weapons can lead to enhanced misdemeanor or felony charges with penalties as severe as multiple year prison terms.
Even if the alleged victim wishes to “drop the charges,” prosecutors will often continue to pursue the case.
It is critical for anyone accused of domestic violence to mount a strong defense strategy early in the process. For more information on domestic violence laws in Michigan, visit our Ann Arbor Domestic Violence page.
Common Defense Strategies
There are several l defense strategies that can be employed when facing domestic violence charges. The most effective approach will depend on the specific circumstances of your case. Common defenses to be explored are:
- False Accusations: Some domestic violence allegations are fabricated or exaggerated to gain advantage in personal disputes over issues like child custody or divorce. A skilled attorney examines inconsistencies in an accuser’s story, such as conflicting timelines or motives for making false claims. For example, even physical evidence such as alleged injuries should be examined against causes by another source or party or the actual context in which they occurred. Learn more about defending against false accusations on our Domestic Violence Defense page.
- Self-Defense: Michigan law allows individuals to use reasonable force to protect themselves from imminent harm. If you acted in self-defense during a domestic altercation, this can be an affirmative defense, preventing a conviction. Lawful self-defense requires that you reasonably believed you were in immediate danger of bodily harm or injury and that your response was proportionate to the threat. Explore more about assault defense strategies.
- Lack of Intent: Domestic violence charges require proof that the accused intended to harm or intended to threaten harm to the victim. If the incident was accidental—such as an unintended push during an argument—a skilled attorney can make the best presentation that there was no willful intent to cause harm. This defense can be particularly effective when balanced against the full body of evidence of the case, such as the alleged victim’s injuries were not consistent with intentional violence.
- Challenging Evidence: In many domestic violence cases, the prosecution’s evidence may rely heavily on witness testimony or exhibit evidence like 911 calls or police videos. A defense attorney should scrutinize this evidence for errors and grounds for legal admissibility such as mishandled evidence or unlawful searches or seizures. Other evidence, such as text messages or home security camera footage, should be obtained and examined against the facts alleged.
Impact of Prior Convictions
Michigan law treats repeat domestic violence offenders more harshly than first-time offenders. A second offense is still a misdemeanor but carries up to one year in jail and a fine of up to $1,000. A third offense in enhanced to a felony charge with potential penalties of up to five years in prison and fines as high as $5,000. Additionally, a domestic assault involving strangulation or an intent to cause great bodily harm or use of a weapon can result in felony charges, even for first-time offenders.
For further details on how prior convictions affect domestic violence sentencing, visit our resource page.
Plea Bargains and First-Time Offender Programs
First-time offenders facing domestic violence charges may be eligible for treatment under a special provision of Michigan law providing the possibility of a deferred judgment of conviction under MCL § 769.4a. This statute requires the consent of both the prosecutor and the court and allows eligible individuals to plead guilty without a judgment of conviction entering on their record. Instead, under this statute, the defendant's judgement of conviction is deferred, pending completion of probation and other court-ordered conditions such as substantial counseling for domestic aggression. Upon successful completion of these requirements, the case is dismissed without a criminal conviction ever entering and the court file becomes nonpublic beginning on the date of sentencing.
This outcome can provide significant benefits to individuals who want to avoid long-term consequences such as a criminal history. However, failing to fulfill probation conditions could result in entry of the judgment of conviction and revocation of the deferred status. Learn more about first-time offender programs.
The Importance of Legal Representation
Given the complexity of domestic violence laws and the potential for severe penalties—including jail time and long-term damage to your reputation—it is essential to work with an experienced criminal defense attorney who understands Michigan law and procedure and has the ability and experience to help you navigate the process and stand up to the government.
In sum, defending against domestic violence charges in Michigan requires a comprehensive understanding of the law, legal defenses, and effective courtroom strategies. Whether through proving false accusations, exposing motives to fabricate or exaggerate, asserting self-defense, or challenging evidence, an experienced attorney can be the difference between conviction and acquittal.
For personalized assistance with your case, contact us today at Simon Criminal Defense.
Fact-Check Summary Against Michigan Law:
- Definition of Domestic Violence: The article accurately reflects Michigan's definition under MCL 750.81(2) regarding individuals involved in domestic relationships.
- Penalties for Domestic Violence: First offense: Correctly described as a misdemeanor punishable by up to 93 days in jail and fines up to $500 (MCL 750.81). Second offense: Accurately described as carrying up to one year in jail and fines up to $1,000. Third offense (felony): Correctly described as carrying penalties up to five years imprisonment and fines up to $5,000 (MCL 750.81(4)).
- Aggravated Domestic Assault: The article correctly outlines penalties for aggravated assault under MCL 750.81a, including misdemeanor penalties for first offenses (up to one year) and felony penalties for repeat offenses (up to five years).
- Self-Defense: The article correctly reflects Michigan's self-defense laws regarding reasonable force in response to imminent harm.
- Plea Bargains/First-Time Offender Programs: The article accurately references MCL § 769.4a, which allows first-time offenders an opportunity for dismissal upon successful completion of probation conditions.
.avif)